Esnoga Bet Emunah
1101 Surrey Trce. SE, Tumwater, WA 98501
Telephone: 360-584-9352 - United States of America
© 2010
E-Mail: gkilli@aol.com
Triennial
Cycle (Triennial Torah Cycle) / Septennial Cycle (Septennial Torah Cycle)
Three and 1/2 year
Lectionary Readings |
Second Year of the Reading Cycle |
Ellul 11, 5770 August
20/21, 2010 |
Second Year of the Shmita Cycle |
Candle Lighting
and Havdalah Times:
Atlanta, Georgia, U.S. Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 8:01 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 8:57 PM |
Brisbane, Australia Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 5:10 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 6:04 PM |
Bucharest, Romania Fri Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 7:57 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 8:59 PM |
Chattanooga, & Cleveland, TN, U.S. Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 8:07 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 9:03 PM |
Jakarta,
Indonesia Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 5:36 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 6:26 PM |
Manila & Cebu, Philippines Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 5:59 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 6:49 PM |
Miami,
FL, U.S. Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 7:35 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 8:27 PM |
Olympia, WA, U.S. Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 7:57 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 9:02 PM |
Murray, KY, & Paris,
TN. U.S. Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 7:23 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 8:20 PM |
San Antonio, TX,
U.S. Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 7:52 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 8:46 PM |
Sheboygan & Manitowoc, WI, US Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 7:30 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 8:32 PM |
Singapore, Singapore Fri. Aug 20, 2010 Candles at 6:55 PM Sat. Aug 21, 2010 Havdalah 7:44 PM |
For other places see: http://chabad.org/calendar/candlelighting.asp
Roll of Honor:
This Torah commentary comes to you courtesy of:
His Honor Rosh Paqid Adon Hillel ben David and beloved
wife HH Giberet Batsheva bat Sarah
His Honor Paqid Adon Mikha ben Hillel
His Honor Paqid Adon David ben Abraham
Her Excellency Giberet Sarai bat Sarah & beloved
family
His Excellency Adon Barth Lindemann & beloved
family
His Excellency Adon John Batchelor & beloved wife
His Excellency Adon Ezra ben Abraham and beloved wife
HE Giberet Karmela bat Sarah,
His Excellency Dr. Adon Yeshayahu ben Yosef and beloved
wife HE Giberet Tricia Foster
His Excellency Adon Yisrael ben Abraham and beloved
wife HE Giberet Elisheba bat Sarah
Her Excellency Giberet Laurie Taylor
His Excellency Dr. Adon Eliyahu ben Abraham and
beloved wife HE Giberet Dr. Elisheba bat Sarah
For their regular and sacrificial giving, providing
the best oil for the lamps, we pray that G-ds richest blessings be upon their
lives and those of their loved ones, together with all Yisrael and her Torah
Scholars, amen ve amen!
Also a great thank you and great blessings be upon all
who send comments to the list about the contents and commentary of the weekly
Torah Seder and allied topics.
If you want to subscribe to our list and ensure that
you never lose any of our commentaries, or would like your friends also to
receive this commentary, please do send me an E-Mail to benhaggai@GMail.com with
your E-Mail or the E-Mail addresses of your friends. Toda Rabba!
Shabbat Nachamu
5
5th
of 7 Sabbaths of the Consolation of Yisrael
Shabbat |
Torah Reading: |
Weekday Torah Reading: |
בְּרֹאשׁ |
|
|
BRosh |
Reader 1 Vayiqra 13:29-31 |
Reader 1 Vayiqra 14:1-4 |
upon the head |
Reader 2 Vayiqra 13:32-34 |
Reader 2 Vayiqra 14:5-8 |
sobre la cabeza |
Reader 3 Vayiqra 13:35-39 |
Reader 3 Vayiqra 14:9-11 |
Vayiqra (Leviticus) 13:29-59 |
Reader 4 Vayiqra 13:40-46 |
|
Ashlamatah: Isaiah 7:20 8:3 + 9:6 |
Reader 5 Vayiqra 13:47-49 |
|
Special: Isaiah 54:1-10 |
Reader 6 Vayiqra 13:50-54 |
Reader 1 Vayiqra 14:1-4 |
Psalm 78:32-39 |
Reader 7 Vayiqra 13:55-59 |
Reader 2 Vayiqra 14:5-8 |
Pirqe Abot
IV:13 |
Maftir:
Vayiqra 13:57-59 |
Reader 3 Vayiqra 14:9-11 |
N.C.: I Tsefet (Peter) 5:1-4 |
Isaiah 54:1-10 |
|
Rashi & Targum
Pseudo Jonathan
for: Vayiqra
(Leviticus) 13:29-59
Rashi |
Targum
Pseudo-Jonathan |
29.
If a man or a woman has a lesion on the head or on the beard [area], |
29. And if a man or a woman have a plague upon the
head, or in the beard, |
30.
the kohen shall look at the lesion, and, behold! its appearance is
deeper than the skin, and in it is a thin golden yellow hair, the kohen shall
pronounce him unclean. It is a nethek, which is tzara'ath of the head or the
beard. |
30.
the priest shall look upon the plague; and, behold, if the appearance
is deeper and whiter than the skin, and yellow hair be in it, in sight like a
thin thread of gold, the priest shall make him unclean; it is a scurvy, a
leprosy in the head or the beard. |
31.
But when the kohen looks at the nethek lesion, and, behold! its
appearance is not deeper than the skin, and there is no black hair in it, the
kohen shall quarantine [the person with] the nethek lesion for seven days. |
31.
But if the priest view the scurfed plague, and, behold, if the
appearance of it be not deeper nor whiter than the skin, and there be no
black hair in it, the priest shall shut up him who hath the scurfed plague
seven days. |
32.
And the kohen shall look at the lesion on the seventh day. And, behold!
the nethek has not spread, and no golden yellow hair was in it, and the
appearance of the nethek is not deeper than the skin, |
32.
And the priest on the seventh day shall look upon the plague; and,
behold, if the plague hath not gone on in breadth, and no yellow hair like
gold be in it, and the appearance of the scurf is not deeper than the skin, |
33.
he shall shave himself, but adjacent to the nethek he shall not shave,
and the kohen shall quarantine [the person with] the nethek again for seven
days. |
33.
he shall cut away the hair which surrounds the scar, but the scurfed
part he must not shave; and the priest shall shut him who hath the scurf,
seven days. |
34.
Then the kohen shall look at the nethek on the seventh day. And,
behold! the nethek did not spread on the skin, and its appearance is not
deeper than the skin, the kohen shall pronounce him clean, and he shall
immerse his garments and become clean. |
34.
Then shall the priest look upon the scurf on the seventh day; and,
behold, if the scar hath not gone on in breadth in the skin, and its
appearance is not deeper nor becoming whiter than the skin, the priest shall
make him to be clean; and he shall wash his clothes and be clean. |
35.
But if the nethek spreads on the skin, after he has been declared
clean, |
35.
But should the breadth of the scar go on in the skin after his
purification, |
36.
the kohen shall look at it, and, behold! the nethek has spread on the
skin, the kohen need not examine for golden yellow hair; it is unclean! |
36.
the priest shall inspect it: and, behold, if the breadth hath
increased, the priest need not look narrowly after the yellow hair; for he is
unclean. |
37.
But if the appearance of the nethek has remained the same, or if black
hair has grown in it, the nethek has healed; he is clean. So the kohen shall
pronounce him clean. |
37.
But if the scar abideth, (without widening,) and black hair hath
sprung up in it, the scar hath healed; he is clean, and the priest shall make
him to be clean. |
38.
If a man or a woman has spots on the skin of their flesh, white spots, |
38.
And if a man or a woman have in the skin of their flesh bright white
spots, |
39.
the kohen shall look, and, behold! there are dim white spots on the
skin of their flesh, it is a bohak [pigmentation] which has spread on the
skin. He is clean. |
39.
the priest shall look, and, behold, if the spots in the skin of their
flesh are a greyish white, it is a bright freckle growing in the skin; he is
clean. |
40.
If a man loses the hair on [the back of] his head, he is bald. He is
clean. |
40.
And if a man's hair fall off from his head, he is bald, but he is
clean. |
41.
And if he loses his hair on the side toward his face, he is bald at the
front. He is clean. |
41.
And if the hair fall away from the brow of his face, he is partly
bald, but he is clean. |
42.
If there is a reddish white lesion on the back or front bald area, it
is a spreading tzara'ath in his back or front bald area. |
42.
But, if his baldness or partial baldness hath in it a white plague
mixed with red, it is a leprosy growing in his baldness or partial baldness. |
43.
So the kohen shall look at it. And, behold! there is a reddish white
se'eith lesion on his back or front bald area, like the appearance of
tzara'ath on the skin of the flesh, |
43. And the priest shall look upon it, and, behold,
if the spot of the plague be white mixed with red in his baldness, or partial
baldness, like the appearance of leprosy in the skin of the flesh, |
44.
He is a man afflicted with tzara'ath; he is unclean. The kohen shall
surely pronounce him unclean; his lesion is on his head. |
44.
he is a leprous man, he is unclean, and the priest shall verily make
him to be unclean, for the plague is on his head. |
45.
And the person with tzara'ath, in whom there is the lesion his garments
shall be torn, his head shall be unshorn, he shall cover himself down to his
mustache and call out, "Unclean! Unclean!" |
45.
And the leper in whom is the plague shall have his clothes rent, and
his hair shall be taken off, going to the shearer's, and his lips shall be
covered; and he shall be clothed like a mourner, and crying, as a herald, he
shall say, Keep off, keep off from the unclean! |
46.
All the days the lesion is upon him, he shall remain unclean. He is
unclean; he shall dwell isolated; his dwelling shall be outside the camp. |
46.
All the days that the plague is in him he shall be unclean, for
unclean he is; he shall dwell alone by himself, to the side of his wife he
must not come nigh, and his habitation shall be without the camp. |
47.
[And as for] the garment that has the lesion of tzara'ath upon it, on a
woolen garment, or on a linen garment, |
47.
And a garment in which is the plague of leprosy, whether a garment of
wool or a garment of linen, |
48.
or on [threads prepared for the] warp or the woof of linen or of wool,
or on leather or on anything made from leather. |
48.
whether in the warp or in the woof, in linen or in woollen, or in a
skin, or in anything made of skin: |
49.
If the lesion on the garment, the leather, the warp or woof [threads]
or on any leather article is deep green or deep red, it is a lesion of
tzara'ath, and it shall be shown to the kohen. |
49.
if the plague be green or red in the garment, or in the skin, whether
in the warp or in the woof, or in anything of leather, it is the plague of
leprosy, and must be shown to the priest. |
50.
The kohen shall look at the lesion, and he shall quarantine [the
article with] the lesion for seven days. |
50.
And the priest shall look upon the plague, and shall shut it up seven
days: |
51.
And he shall look at the lesion on the seventh day. [If] the lesion has
spread on the garment, or on the warp or woof [threads], or on the leather or
on any article made from leather, the lesion is a malignant tzara'ath ; it is
unclean. |
51.
and he shall look upon the plague on the seventh day, and if the
plague hath become wider in the garment, whether in the warp or woof, or in
the skin, or anything made of skin, it is a manifest plague of leprosy, it is
unclean. |
52.
And he shall burn the garment, the warp or woof [threads] of wool or of
linen, or any leather article which has the lesion upon it, for it is a
malignant tzara'ath; it shall be burned in fire. |
52.
|
53.
But if the kohen looks, and, behold! the lesion has not spread on the
garment, the warp or woof [threads], or any leather article, |
53.
But if the priest look, and, behold, the width of the plague hath not
advanced in the garment, in warp or woof, or anything of skin, |
54.
the kohen shall order, and they shall wash what the lesion is upon, and
he shall quarantine it again for seven days. |
54.
let the priest direct that they wash the material which hath the
plague in it, and shut it up a second seven days. |
55.
Then the kohen shall look [at it] after the lesion has been washed.
And, behold! the lesion has not changed in appearance, and the lesion has not
spread; it is unclean. You shall burn it in fire. It is a penetrating lesion
on the worn or new [article]. |
55.
And the priest shall look after they have washed the plague, and,
behold, the (condition of the) plague hath not altered from what it was, and
the plague hath not advanced in its size, it is unclean, thou shalt burn it
in the fire, for the leprosy is deep in its bareness (or in its outward
side). |
56.
But if the kohen looks [at it] after it has been washed, and behold!
the lesion has become dimmer, he shall tear it out of the garment, out of the
leather, or out of the warp or woof [threads]. |
56.
And if the priest observe, and, behold, the plague hath become dim,
then shall he tear it out of the garment, or from the leather, or out of the
warp or the woof. |
57.
And if it appears again on the garment, the warp or woof [threads] or
any leather article, it is a recurrent growth [of the lesion]. You shall burn
it in fire [the article] upon which the lesion is [found]. |
57.
But if it reappear in the garment, or in the warp or woof, or in
anything of skin, and maketh increase, thou shalt burn such material which
hath the plague in it. |
58.
But the garment, the warp or woof [threads] or any leather article
which is washed, and the lesion disappears from them, shall be immersed a
second time, and it shall be clean. |
58.
And the garment, or the warp or woof, or anything of skin, which thou
shalt wash and the plague depart from it shall be washed a second time, and
it shall be clean. |
59.
This is the law of a lesion of tzara'ath on a woolen or linen garment,
warp or woof threads, or any leather article, to render it clean or unclean. |
59.
This is the law for the plague of leprosy in a garment of woollen or
of linen, or the warp or the woof, or anything of skin, to make it to be
clean or to be unclean. |
|
|
Welcome to the
World of Pshat Exegesis
In
order to understand the finished work of the Pshat mode of interpretation of
the Torah, one needs to take into account that the Pshat is intended to
produce a catechetical output, whereby a question/s is/are raised and an
answer/a is/are given using the seven Hermeneutic Laws of R. Hillel and as well
as the laws of Hebrew Grammar and Hebrew expression.
The
Seven Hermeneutic Laws of R. Hillel are as follows
[cf.
http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=472&letter=R]:
1.
Ḳal va-ḥomer:
"Argumentum a minori ad majus" or "a majori ad minus";
corresponding to the scholastic proof a fortiori.
2.
Gezerah shavah:
Argument from analogy. Biblical passages containing synonyms or homonyms are
subject, however much they differ in other respects, to identical definitions
and applications.
3.
Binyan ab mi-katub eḥad: Application of a provision found in one passage
only to passages which are related to the first in content but do not contain
the provision in question.
4.
Binyan ab mi-shene ketubim:
The same as the preceding, except that the provision is generalized from two
Biblical passages.
5.
Kelal u-Peraṭ and Peraṭ u-kelal: Definition of the general by the
particular, and of the particular by the general.
6.
Ka-yoẓe bo mi-maḳom aḥer: Similarity in content to another
Scriptural passage.
7.
Dabar ha-lamed me-'inyano:
Interpretation deduced from the context.
Reading Assignment:
The
Torah Anthology, Volume 11, The Divine Service, pp. 292-299
By:
Hakham Yitschak Magrisso
Translated
by Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan
Moznaim
Publishing Corporation, 1991
Rashis Commentary for Vayiqra (Lev.) 13:29-59
Chapter
13
29 on the head or on the beard [area] Scripture
comes to distinguish between a lesion in a place where hair grows and a lesion
in a place of flesh, namely, that in one [case, i.e., on flesh], the sign [of
uncleanness] is white hair, while in the other [case, i.e., on the area of
hair], the sign [of uncleanness] is golden-yellow hair.-[Torath Kohanim 5:5]
30 and in it is a... golden-yellow hair
[meaning] that the black hair in it has turned golden-yellow.
It is a nethek This is the name of the
lesion [of tzaraath when it occurs] on an area of [skin where] hair [grows].
31 and there is no black hair in it Thus, if
there was black hair inside it, he is clean and does not require quarantine,
for black hair in a nethek is a sign of cleanness, as the verse (37) says,
"or if black hair has grown in it, [the nethek has healed; it is
clean]."[Torath Kohanim 13:125]
32 And, behold! the nethek did not spread Thus, if
[the nethek] did spread, or if it had golden-yellow hair in it, he is unclean.
33 he shall shave himself around
the nethek.
but adjacent to the nethek
he shall not shave [I.e.,] he shall leave two
hairs close to it all around, in order that any spread of the nethek will be
discernible, so that, if it spreads, it will pass the hairs and go out to the
shaven area.-[Torath Kohanim 13:133]
35 after he has been declared clean From
here, we know only that [the lesion is pronounced unclean] if it spreads after
dismissal. How do we know [that it is unclean if it spreads] at the end of the
first week [of quarantine] or at the end of the second week [of quarantine]?
Because Scripture [uses a double expression and] says, פָּשׂה
יִפְשֶׂה , it spreads, [denoting that he is unclean if it spreads] in
any case.-[Torath Kohanim 13:134]
37 black hair How do we know that even
yellow or red [hair], which are not golden- yellow? Because Scripture says, [ שָׁחֽר ] וְשֵׂעָר [lit., and black hair, but here meaning, or
if black hair. Instead of using the expected אוֹ , or, the Torah used וְ , an inclusive term, which comes to include yellow
and red hair in the nethek as signs of cleanness, just like black hair. See
Beer Basadeh] (Torath Kohanim 13:137). The term צָהֽב means: resembling the appearance of gold (Torath
Kohanim 13:122). צָהֽב is the same as זָהֽב , golden [because צ and ז are interchangeable], orable in Old French, gold-colored, or
orpale, pale gold.
he is clean. So the kohen shall pronounce him clean- But, an
unclean person whom the kohen pronounces clean, is not clean. -[Torath Kohanim
13:140]
38 spots Heb. בֶּהָרֽת , spots.
39 dim white I.e., their whiteness is not bright, but dim.
it is a bohak Like the whiteness that
appears on the flesh of a red man, called ros [in Old French, rosso in
Italian], between the areas of his redness [i.e., flesh color]. This [white
pigmentation] is called בּֽהַק , just like a freckled man, whose skin between one
freckle and another shines brightly (מַבְהִיק) with pure whiteness.
40 he is bald. He is clean Clean of the
uncleanness of nethek lesions (Torath Kohanim ; Baraitha of Rabbi Ishmael 1:5).
I.e., this case is not judged by the signs of the head and beard, which are
places of hair (see verses 2937). Rather, [it is judged] by the signs of a
lesion on the skin of the flesh, namely: 1) white hair, 2) healthy flesh, and
3) spread.
41 at the front of his head [The
area] from the slope of the crown toward ones face is called גַּבַּחַת forehead, and included in this are the temples
on either side as well. [The area] from the slope of the crown toward ones
back is called קָרַחַת , the back of the head.-[Torath Kohanim 13:144]
42 a reddish-white lesion blended
[of red and white]. How do we know [that the lesion is also unclean if it has]
other colors? Because Scripture says, like the appearance of tzaraath on the
skin of the flesh (verse 43), i.e., appearing like the tzaraath dealt with in
the passage of [lesions of the] skin of the flesh, [which begins with] If a
man has [seeith, sapachat or bahereth] on the skin of his flesh (verse 13:2).
And what is stated regarding it [i.e., regarding a lesion on the skin]? That
one becomes unclean through [it, if it appears as one of] four shades [namely:
1) the snow- white of bahereth ; 2) the white as lime of the Holy Temple of
the secondary form (sapachat) of bahereth ; 3) the white as white wool of
seeith ; and 4) the white as a membrane that covers an egg of the secondary
(sapachat) form of seeith (Negaim 1:1), and that it is judged with [a
possible] two weeks [of quarantine], and not like the appearance of tzaraath
stated concerning inflamed areas and burns, which is judged with [only] one
[possible] week [of quarantine], and is also unlike the appearance of nethek
lesions, [which are tzaraath found] in hairy places, which do not become
unclean through the four shades [as above].
44 His lesion is on his head I know
only that [these laws apply to those stricken with] nethek lesions [the
tzaraath of the head]. From where [do I know] to include other afflicted
people? Therefore, Scripture says: טַמֵּא
יְטַמְּאֶנּוּ , shall surely pronounce him unclean. [The double
expression comes] to include them all. Concerning them all, Scripture says:
his garments shall be torn... (verses 4546). -[Torath Kohanim 13:154]
45 torn Heb. פְרֻמִים , torn.-[Moed Katan 15a]
unshorn Heb. פָּרוּעַ , with hair grown long.- [Moed Katan 15a]
He shall cover himself down to his mustache like a
mourner.-[Torath Kohanim 13:154]
mustache Heb. שָָׂפָם , the hair on the lips (שְׂפָתַיִם) [i.e., the mustache], grenon in Old French.
and he shall call out," Unclean! Unclean!" He
announces that he is unclean, so that everyone should stay away from
him.-[Torath Kohanim 13:155]
46 He shall dwell isolated [meaning]
that other unclean people [not stricken with tzaraath] shall not abide with
him. Our Sages said: "Why is he different from other unclean people,
that he must remain isolated? Since, with his slander, he caused a separation
[i.e., a rift] between man and wife or between man and his fellow, he too,
shall be separated [from society]."- [Arachin 16b] [This rationale is
based on the premise that a person is stricken with tzaraath as a result of
his talking לְשׁוֹן
הָרַע , i.e., speaking derogatorily of others, although he may be
telling the truth.]
outside the camp Outside the three camps [of
Israel, namely: 1) the camp of the Shechinah, in which the Mishkan was located;
2) the Levite camp, and 3) the camp of the Israelites].-[Torath Kohanim 13:157,
Pes. 67a]
48 of linen or of wool Heb. לַפִּשְׁתִּים וְלַצָּמֶר , of linen or of wool. [Here the ל , usually meaning to, means
of.]
or the leather This [refers to] leather
upon which no work has been performed.
or anything made from leather This
[refers] to leather upon which work has been performed.
49 deep green Heb. יְרַקְרַק , the greenest of greens.-[Torath Kohanim 13:161]
deep red - אֲדַמְדָּם , the reddest of reds.-[Torath Kohanim 13:161]
51 a malignant tzarath Heb. צָרַעַת מַמְאֶרֶת , an expression similar to a pricking briar (סִלּוֹן
מַמְאִיר) , (Ezek. 28:24), poρant in Old French, stinging, pricking.
The midrashic explanation is: Place a curse (מְאֵרָה) upon it [the item afflicted with tzaraath], that
you shall not derive benefit from it.- [Torath Kohanim 13:166]
52 of wool or of linen Heb. בַּצֶּמֶר אוֹ
בַפִּשְׁתִּים , of wool or of linen. [The ב , which usually means in, here means of.] This
is its simple meaning. Its midrashic explanation is, however: [The words, וְשָָׂרַף
אֶת
בֶּגֶד...בַּצֶּמֶר אוֹ
בַפִּשְׁתִּים , can be understood literally, as: And he shall
burn the garment...in the wool or in the linen. Thus,] one might think that
[when burning the unclean garment,] one is required to bring wool shearings and
stalks of flax and burn them along with it. Scripture, therefore, says [at the
end of this verse], for it... ; it shall be burned in fire. [I.e., it alone]
it does not require anything else [to be burned] along with it. If so, why does
Scripture say, "in the wool or the linen"? To exclude [from the
requirement of burning] the edges (אִימְרִיּוֹת) if they are of another material (Torath Kohanim
13:167). אִימְרִיּוֹת means edges, like אִימְרָא , border.
54 what the lesion is upon One
might think that [one need wash] the area of the lesion alone. Scripture, therefore,
says, what the lesion is upon, [meaning, the garment upon which the lesion is
found. But if so,] one might think that the entire garment requires washing.
Scripture, therefore, says, [after] the lesion [has been washed], (verse 55)
[teaching us that only the lesion must be washed, not the entire garment]. So
how [do we reconcile this apparent discrepancy]? He must wash part of the
garment with it.-[see Torath Kohanim 13:169]
55 after [the lesion] has been washed Heb. הֻכַּבֵּס . This is an expression of having been done,
[i.e., the passive voice].
the lesion has not changed in appearance i.e., it
has not become dimmer in color.
and the lesion has not spread We
understand that if the lesion neither changed [in color] nor spread, it is
unclean, and it goes without saying that if it did not change in color but did
spread, [it is unclean]. If it changed in color [but still was a shade that
makes it unclean] yet did not spread, we do not know what one should do with it.
Therefore, Scripture says, he shall quarantine [the article with] the lesion
(verse 50), in any case. That is what Rabbi Judah says. [However,] the Sages
say [that since the change in color was still within the unclean shades, the
lesion is not considered to be changed at all; it is the same lesion that has
already had two weeks of quarantine, and is now deemed definitely unclean], as
is stated in Torath Kohanim (13:171). I have alluded to [only a portion of]
this [Midrash] here in order to explain all the different aspects of this
verse.
it is a penetrating lesion Heb. פְּחֶתֶת
הִוא .
[This expression] denotes holes [i.e., penetrations], as the verse says, in
one of the pits (פְּחָתִים) (II Sam. 17:9). That is to say, [in this
context it means that the lesion] is deep, [i.e.,] it appears as if it is
sunken.-[Torath Kohanim 13:172]
on the worn or new [article] - בְּקָרַחְתּוֹ
אוֹ
בְגַבַּחְתּוֹ , as the Targum [Onkelos] renders: בִּשְׁחִיקוּתֵיהּ אוֹ
בְּחַדְתּוּתֵהּ , in its worn state or in its new state.
the worn Heb. בְּקָרַחְתּוֹ . Old, worn out garments, and because of the
midrashic explanation, that this language is necessary for a גְּזֵרָה
שָׁוָה here [i.e., a link between two seemingly unrelated passages
through common terms, thereby inferring the laws of one passage from the laws
of the other, as follows]: How do we know that if a lesion on a garment spreads
[throughout the entire garment], it is clean? Because [Scripture] states קָרַחַת and גַּבַּחַת in the context of [lesions that appear on] man
(verse 42), and here, in the context of [lesion on] garments, [Scripture] also
states קָרַחַת and גַּבַּחַת ; just as there [in the case of lesions on man],
if it spread over the entire body, he is clean (verses 1213), so too, here, [in
the case of lesion on garments,] if it spread over the entire garment, it is clean
(San. 88a), Scripture adopts the [unusual] expressions קָרַחַת and גַּבַּחַת . However, concerning the explanation and
translation [of these terms], the simple meaning is that קָרַחַת means old and גַּבַּחַת means new. It is as though it were written, [It
is a lesion on] its end or its beginning, for קָרַחַת means back [i.e., at the end of the garments
life, when it is old,] and גַּבַּחַת means front [i.e., the beginning of its life,
when it is new]. This is just as is written, And if [he loses hair] at the
front of his head, [he is bald at the front (גַּבַּח) ] (verse 41). And קָרַחַת refers from the crown toward his back. Thus it is
explained in Torath Kohanim (13:144).
56 he shall tear it He shall tear the afflicted
area from the garment and burn that area [of garment].- [Torath Kohanim 13:174]
57 it is a recurrent growth - פּֽרַחַת , something that grows recurrently.
You shall burn it in fire the
entire garment.
58 and the lesion disappears from them If, after
they first washed [the article] by order of the kohen, the lesion disappeared
completely from it... [then]
shall be immersed a second time [The
word וְכֻבַּס in this verse] means immersion [in a mikvah. See
Torath Kohanim 13:179]. In Targum [Onkelos], the translation of all the
instances of כִּבּוּס in this whole section is to cleanse, clean (וְיִתְחַוֵּר) , with this one exception [in our verse]. Here
the meaning is not cleansing but rather immersion [in a mikvah]. Thus
Targum [Onkelos] here [in translating the word וְכֻבַּס ] says וְיִצְטַבַּע , and it shall be immersed. Likewise, wherever
the כִבּוּס of garments refers to immersion [in a mikvah], it
is translated in the Targum as וְיִצְטַבַּע .
Ketubim: Tehillim
(Psalm) 78:32-39
RASHI |
TARGUM |
1.
A maskil of Asaph. Hearken, my people, to my instruction, extend your
ear to the words of my mouth. |
1. A teaching of the Holy Spirit, composed by
Asaph. Hear, O my people, my Torah; incline your ears to the utterances of my
mouth. |
2. I shall open my mouth with a parable; I shall
express riddles from time immemorial. |
2. I will open my mouth in a proverb; I will
declare riddles from ancient times. |
3. That we heard and we knew them, and our
forefathers told us. |
3. Which we have heard and known, and which our
fathers told to us. |
4. We shall not hide from their sons; to the last
generation they will recite the praises of the Lord, and His might and His
wonders, which He performed. |
4. We will not hide it from their sons, recounting
the psalms of the LORD to a later generation, and His might, and the wonders
that He performed. |
5. And He established testimony in Jacob, and He
set down a Torah in Israel, which He commanded our forefathers to make them
known to their sons. |
5. And He established a witness among those of
the house of Jacob, and He decreed a Torah among those of the
house of Israel, which He commanded our fathers to teach to their sons. |
6. In order that the last generation might know,
sons who will be born should tell their sons. |
6. So that another generation, sons still to be
born, should know; they will arise and tell it to their children. |
7. And they should put their hope in God, and not
forget the deeds of God, and keep His commandments. |
7.
And they will place their hope in God, and not forget the works of God,
and they will keep His commandments. |
8. And they should not be as their forefathers, a
stubborn and rebellious generation, who did not prepare its heart and whose
spirit was not faithful to God. |
8. And they will not be like their fathers, a stubborn
and vexing generation, a generation whose heart was not firm with its
lord, and its spirit was not faithful to God. |
9. The sons of Ephraim, armed archers, retreated
on the day of battle. |
9. While they were living in Egypt, the
sons of Ephraim became arrogant; they calculated the appointed time, and
erred; they went out thirty years before the appointed time, with weapons
of war, and warriors bearing bows. They turned around and were
killed on the day of battle. |
10. They did not keep the covenant of God, and
they refused to follow His Torah. |
10. Because they did not keep the covenant
of God and refused to walk in His Torah. |
11. They forgot His deeds and His wonders, which
He showed them. |
11. And the people, the house of Israel,
forgot His deeds and His wonders that He showed them. |
12. Before their forefathers He wrought wonders,
in the land of Egypt, the field of Zoan. |
12. In front of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and
the tribes of their ancestors, He performed wonders in the land of Egypt,
the field of Tanis. |
13. He split the sea and took them across, He made
the water stand as a heap. |
13. He split the sea with the staff of Moses
their leader, and made them to pass through, and He made the water stand
up, fastened like a skin bottle. |
14. He led them with a cloud by day, and all night
with the light of fire. |
14. And He guided them with the cloud by day, and
all of the night with the light of fire. |
15. He split rocks in the desert and gave them to
drink as [from] great deeps. |
15. He split mountains with the staff of Moses
their leader in the wilderness; and He gave drink as if from the great
deeps. |
16. He drew flowing water from a rock and brought
down water like rivers. |
16. And He brought forth streams of water from
the rock, and He made water come down like flowing rivers. |
17. But they continued further to sin against Him,
to provoke the Most High in the desert. |
17. But they continued still to sin before Him,
to provoke anger in the presence of the Most High in the dry wilderness.
|
18. They tried God in their heart by requesting
food for their craving. |
18. And they tempted God in their heart, to ask
for food for their souls. |
19. And they spoke against God; they said,
"Can God set a table in the desert? |
19. And they complained in the presence of
the LORD; they said, "Is there the ability in the presence of God
to set a table in the wilderness?" |
20. True, He struck a rock and water flowed, and
streams flooded. Can He give meat too? Can He prepare flesh for His
people?" |
20. Behold, He already has smitten a rock,
and water gushed out, and streams flowed; is He also able to give bread, or
to arrange food for His people? |
21. Therefore, God heard and was incensed; fire
was kindled against Jacob, and also wrath ascended upon Israel. |
21. Then it was heard in the presence of
God, and He was angry, and fire was made to come up on those of the
house of Jacob, and also harsh anger came up on Israel. |
22. Because they did not believe in God and did
not trust in His salvation. |
22. For they did not believe in God, and did not
put their trust in His redemption. |
23. And He had commanded the skies from above, and
He had opened the portals of heaven. |
23. And He commanded the skies above and He opened
the windows of heaven. |
24. He had rained upon them manna to eat, and He had
given them corn of heaven. |
24. And He made descend on them manna to eat, and
He gave them the grain of heaven. |
25. Men ate the bread of the mighty; He sent them
provisions for satisfaction. |
25. The sons of men ate food that came
down from the abode of angels; He sent them provisions unto satiety. |
26. He caused the east wind to set forth in
heaven, and He led the south wind with His might. |
26. He made the east wind move in the
heavens, and guided the south wind by His strength. |
27. He rained down flesh upon them like dust, and,
like the sand of the seas, winged fowl. |
27. And He made flesh descend on them like
dust, and flying fowl like the sand of the sea. |
28. And He let it fall in the midst of their camp,
around their dwellings. |
28. And He made them fall in the midst of His
camp, round about its tents. |
29. They ate and were very satisfied, and He
brought them their desire. |
29. And they ate and were very satisfied; so He
brought to them their craving. |
30. They were not estranged from their desire; while
their food was still in their mouth, |
30. They did not turn from their craving, still
their food was in their mouth |
31. The wrath of God ascended upon them and slew
[some] of their stoutest and caused the chosen of Israel to fall. |
31. And the anger of God went up on them, and He
slew some of their champions, and He subdued the young men of Israel. |
32. Despite all this, they sinned again and did
not believe despite His wonders. |
32. For all this they sinned again, and did not
believe in His wonders. |
33. And He ended their days in vanity and their
years in terror. |
33. And He ended their days with nothingness, and
their years with disaster. |
34. When He slew them, they would seek Him, and
they would repent and pray to God. |
34. Whenever He killed them, they sought Him,
repenting; and they will repent and pray in the presence of God. |
35. And they remembered that God is their rock and
the Most High God is their Redeemer. |
35. And they remembered, for God is their strength,
and the Most High God is their Redeemer. |
36. They beguiled Him with their mouth, and with
their tongue they lied to Him. |
36. And
they enticed Him with their mouth, and they lie to Him with their tongue. |
37. Their heart was not sincere with Him; they
were not faithful in His covenant. |
37. Because their heart was not faithful to
Him, and they were not faithful in His covenant. |
38. But He is merciful, He expiates iniquity and
does not destroy; many times. He takes back His wrath and does not arouse all
His anger. |
38. But He is merciful, atoning for their sins,
and does not destroy them; and He frequently turns from His
anger, and He will not hasten all His wrath against them. |
39. He remembers that they are flesh, a spirit
that goes away and does not return. |
39. And He remembers that they are sons of flesh,
a breath that goes away and does not return. |
|
|
Rashis Commentary on
Tehillim (Psalm) 78:32-39
2 ...my mouth with a parable They are
the words of Torah.
4 We shall not hide from their sons We, too,
shall not hide [these words] from our fathers sons by not letting them know
what they told us.
7 their hope Heb. כסלם , their hope, and so (Job 31:24): If I made gold
my hope (כסלי) .
8 as their forefathers who were
in Egypt and in the desert.
9 The sons of Ephraim who left
Egypt forcefully before the end [of the exile] and trusted in their might and
in their arrows. Ultimately, they retreated and fled on the day of battle, as
is delineated (I Chron. 7:21): and the men of Gath, who were born in the land,
slew them.
archers Heb. רומי , who cast and shoot, as (Exod. 15:1): cast (רמה) into
the sea.
12 Before their forefathers He
wrought wonders (NeverthelessShem Ephraim) Afterwards, when the end arrived,
they too continued to sin against Him, as he further concludes. (Another
explanationShem Ephraim) Before their forefathers Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob
came beside the sea, and the Holy One, blessed be He, showed them how He was
redeeming their children.
13 as a heap Heb. נד , a tall heap, as Onkelos renders (Exod. 15:8):
the flowing water stood up like a נֵד , stood up like a wall.
15 He split rocks (Exod. 17:6): and you
shall strike the rock.
and He gave them to drink as [from] great deeps in the
great deeps. Even as they went through the midst of the sea, whose waters are
salty, He sweetened fountains for them in the midst of the sea.
16 and brought down water like rivers [Water]
that was flowing from the well. The princes would make a line with their staffs
and the water would be drawn after them to the encampment of each tribe, as the
matter that is stated (Num. 21:18): by the order of the lawgiver, with their
staffs, as is explained in tractate Makkoth.
17 to provoke Heb. למרות , to provoke, as (Deut. 9:7): you have been
provoking (ממרים) .
20 flesh Heb. שְׁאֵר , flesh.
21 fire was kindled against Jacob Heb. נשקה , as (Ezek. 39:9): and make fires and heat up (והשיקו) , which is an expression of heating and burning. As it is
written (Num. 11:1): and Gods fire broke out against them.
25 bread of the mighty Bread of
the angels. Another explanation: אַבִּירִים means אֵבָרִים , limbs, for it was absorbed into the limbs, and
they did not have to excrete.
26 He caused the east wind to set forth (Num.
11:31): And a wind set forth from the Lord, and it made quails fly.
30 They were not estranged from their desire They did
not become estranged from their desire, for they achieved all their desire.
Another explanation: לא זרוּ
מתאותם They were not distanced from their desire until the retribution
came upon them. While their food was still in their mouth, the wrath of the
Lord (sic), etc.
31 and...the chosen of Israel The
chosen of them and the men of the assembly, הָאסַפסוּף (Num. 11:4). They are the elders, as it is said
(Num. 11: 16): Assemble (אספו) to Me, etc.
34 When He slew them, etc. Yet all
this was not in truth, but with guile in their mouth and by lying with their
tongue.
37 Their heart was not sincere as with
their mouth.
38 But He is merciful to them
and constantly expiates their iniquity, and He did not destroy them.
many times Many times He withdraws His wrath from them, and even
if He punishes them, He does not arouse all His anger but little by little,
because He remembers that they are flesh and that the evil inclination is
hidden in their heart. That is a spirit that goes away when they die, and
that spirit does not return to them in the world to come. When they are
resurrected, the evil inclination will have no control over them. A spirit
that goes away and does not return cannot be explained to mean their spirit of
life, because if you say so, you have denied the resurrection of the dead.
In this manner, it is explained in Aggadath Tehillim (Mid Ps. 78:8).
Ashlamatah:
Isaiah 7:20 8:3 + 9:6
Rashi |
Targum |
18.
Ά And it shall be on that day, that the Lord shall whistle to the
"fly" that is at the edge of the canals of Egypt, and to the
"bee" that is in the land of Assyria. |
18.
And it will come to pass in that time that the LORD will call to a people of
military units of mighty men that are as numerous as flies, and will bring
them from the land of Egypt, and to the tough men of the armies who are
powerful as bees, and bring them from the ends of the land of Assyria. |
19.
And they shall come and all of them shall rest in the desolate valleys
and in the clefts of the rocks and in all the thornbushes and in all the
shrines. |
19.
And they will come and all of them dwell in the squares of the city, and in
the clefts of the rocks, and in all the deserts of thornbushes, and in all of
the famed buildings. |
20.
On that day, the Lord shall shave with the great razor on the other
side of the river, on the king of Assyria, the head and the hair of the legs,
and also the beard shall be entirely removed. |
20.
In that time the LORD will kill by means of them as someone is slain with a
sharp sword, with nets among the inhabitants in the areas beyond the river
by means of the king of Assyria the king and the people of his armies He
will destroy as one, and also the rulers. |
21.
And it shall come to pass on that day, a man shall keep alive a heifer
of the herd and two sheep. |
21.
And it will come to pass in that time that a man will preserve a young cow
and two sheep. |
22.
And it shall be, because of the plentiful milk produced, that he shall
eat cream, for everyone left in the land will eat cream and honey. |
22.
And it will come to pass that because of the abundance of good he will eat
curd; for all the righteous/generous who are left in the midst of the land
will be nurtured with curd and honey. |
23.
And it shall come to pass, that every place where there were a
thousand vines for a thousand pieces of silver, will be for the worms and the
thorns. |
23.
And it will come to pass in that time that in every place where there used to
be a thousand vines, woth a thousand mina of silver, will be turned into
briers and thorns. |
24.
With arrows and with a bow shall one come there, for the whole land
shall be worms and thorns. |
24.
With arrows and bows they will come there, for all the land will be briers
and thorns. |
25.
And all the mountains that will be dug with a spade-the fear of worms
and thorns shall not come there; it shall be for the pasture of oxen and for
the treading of sheep. |
25.
and as for all the hills of the house of Judah which were tilled with a hoe,
you will not come there for fear of briers and thorn, but it will become a
place where herds of oxen lie and a place where folds of sheep stay. |
|
|
1.
And the Lord said to me, "Take for yourself a large scroll, and
write on it in common script, to hasten loot, speed the spoils. |
1.
And the LORD said to me: Take a large tablet and write upon it in clear
writing, He is hastening to plunder the spoil and take away the booty. |
2.
And I will call to testify for Myself trustworthy witnesses, Uriah the
priest and Zechariah the son of Jeberechiah." |
2.
And I will get reliable witnesses before Me, the curses which I threatened to
bring in the prophecy of Uriah the priest, behold they have come,; even so
all the consolations which I promised to bring in the prophecy of Zechariah
the son of Jeberekiah I am about to bring back. |
3.
And I was intimate with the prophetess, and she conceived, and she
bore a son, and the Lord said to me, "Call his name
Maher-shalal-hash-baz. |
3.
And I went unto the prophetess, and she became pregnant and bore a son. Then
the LORD said to me, Call his name He is hatening to plunder the spoil and
to take away the booty |
4.
For, when the lad does not yet know to call, 'Father' and 'mother,'
the wealth of Damascus and the plunder of Samaria shall be carried off before
the king of Assyria." |
4.
for before the child knows how to cry My father or My mother, the
possessions of Damascus and the booty of Samaria will be captured before the
king of Assyria. |
|
|
1.
The people who walked in darkness, have seen a great light; those who
dwell in the land of the shadow of death, light shone upon them. |
1.
The people, the house of Israel, who walked in Egypt as in darkness have come
out to see a great light; those who dwelt in the land of the shadows of
death, on them light shined. |
2.
You have aggrandized this nation; you have magnified the joy for them;
they have rejoiced over You like the joy of harvest, as they rejoice when
they divide spoils. |
2. You have increased the people, the house of
Israel, you have increased their joy; they rejoice before You as with the joy
of war victors, as men who rejoice when they divide the spoil. |
3.
For, the yoke of his burden and the staff of his shoulder, the rod of
the one who oppressed him have You broken, as on the day of Midian. |
3.
For You have removed the yoke of his mastery and the rule of his tribulation,
the ruler who was subjugating him is broken as on the day of Midian. |
4.
For every victory shout sounds with clamor, and garments wallow in
blood, but this shall be burnt, consumed by fire. |
4.
For all their dealing is with wickedness/Lawlessness; they are defiled with
sins, even as a garment kneaded with blood whose stain marks are not cleansed
from it, just as there is no use for it except to be burned in the fire.
Therefore the Gentiles who are strong as the fire will come upon them and
kill them. |
5.
For a child has been born to us, a son given to us, and the authority
is upon his shoulder, and the wondrous adviser, the mighty God, the
everlasting Father, called his name, "the prince of peace." |
5.
The prophet said to the house of David: For to us a child is born, to us a
son is given; and he will accept the Law upon himself to keep it, and his
name will be called before the Wonderful Counsellor, the Mighty God, existing
forever, The Messiah in whose days peace will increase upon us. |
6.
To him who increases the authority, and for peace without end, on David's
throne and on his kingdom, to establish it and to support it with justice and
with righteousness; from now and to eternity, the zeal of the Lord of Hosts
shall accomplish this. |
6.
Great pride will belong to those who perform the Law, and for those who keep
peace there will be no end, upon the throne of David and upon his kingdom. To
establish it and to build it with judgment and with virtue from this time
forth and forever. By the Memra of the LORD of hosts this will be done. |
|
|
Special
Ashlamatah Isaiah 54:1-10
Rashi |
Targum |
1.
"Sing you barren woman who has not borne; burst out into song and
jubilate, you who have not experienced birth pangs, for the children of the
desolate one are more than the children of the married woman," says the
Lord. |
1.
Sing, O Jerusalem who was as a barren woman who did not bear; shout in
singing and exult, [you who were] as a woman who did not become pregnant! For
the children of desolate Jerusalem will be more than the children of
inhabited Rome, says the LORD. |
2.
Widen the place of your tent, and let them stretch forth the curtains
of your habitations, do not spare; lengthen your cords and strengthen your
stakes. |
2.
Enlarge the place of your camping, and cause the cities of your land to be
inhabited; hold not back, increase the people of your armies and strengthen
your rulers. |
3.
For right and left shall you prevail, and your seed shall inherit
nations and re-people desolate cities. |
3.
For you will be strengthened to the south and to the north, and
your sons will possess peoples and will cause desolate cities to be
inhabited. |
4.
Fear not, for you shall not be ashamed, and be not embarrassed for you
shall not be put to shame, for the shame of your youth you shall forget, and
the disgrace of your widowhood you shall no longer remember. |
4.
Fear not, for you will not be ashamed; be not confounded, for you will not be
put to shame; for you will forget the shame of your youth, and the reproaches
of your widowhood you will remember no more. |
5.
For your Master is your Maker, the Lord of Hosts is His name, and your
Redeemer, the Holy One of Israel, shall be called the God of all the earth. |
5.
For your Maker is your husband, the LORD of hosts is His name; and the Holy
One of Israel is your Redeemer, the God of the whole earth he is called. |
6.
For, like a wife who is deserted and distressed in spirit has the Lord
called you, and a wife of one's youth who was rejected, said your God. |
6.
For the Shekhinah of the LORD has summoned [you] like a wife forsaken and
distressed in spirit, like a wife of youth who is cast off, says your God. |
7.
"For a small moment have I forsaken you, and with great mercy
will I gather you. |
7.
"In a little anger I forsook you, but with great compassion I will
bring your exiles near. |
8.
With a little wrath did I hide My countenance for a moment from you,
and with everlasting kindness will I have compassion on you," said your
Redeemer, the Lord. |
8.
In a brief hour, for a time, I took up the face of my Shekhinah from you,
but with everlasting benefits which do not cease I will have compassion on
you, says the LORD, your Redeemer. |
9.
"For this is to Me [as] the waters of Noah, as I swore that the
waters of Noah shall never again pass over the earth, so have I sworn neither
to be wroth with you nor to rebuke you. |
9.
This is like the days of Noah before Me: as I swore by my Memra (Word) that
the waters of the flood which were in the days of Noah should no more go over
the earth, so I have sworn that my anger will not turn upon you and I will
not rebuke you. |
10.
For the mountains shall depart and the hills totter, but My kindness
shall not depart from you, neither shall the covenant of My peace
totter," says the Lord, Who has compassion on you. |
10.
For the mountains may pass and the hills be split, but My goodness shall not
pass from you, Jerusalem, and My covenant of peace shall not be cast away,
says He who is about to have compassion on you, says the LORD. |
|
|
1 Tsefet (Peter) 5:1-4
CLV[1] |
Magiera
Peshitta NT[2] |
Greek[3] |
Delitzsch[4] |
1.
The elders, then, among you I am entreating (who am a fellow elder and a
witness of the sufferings of Christ, and a participant of the glory about to
be revealed), |
1. Now I ask of the elders who are among you, I, an
elder, your friend and a witness of the sufferings of Christ and a participant
of his glory that is going to be revealed, |
1. Πρεσβυτέρους
τοὺς ἐν ὑμῖν
παρακαλῶ ὁ
συμπρεσβύτερος
καὶ μάρτυς τῶν
τοῦ Χριστοῦ
παθημάτων, ὁ καὶ
τῆς μελλούσης ἀποκαλύπτεσθαι
δόξης κοινωνός·
|
אֶת־הַזְּקֵנִים
אֲשֶׁר
בְּקִרְבְּכֶם
אַזְהִיר
אֲנִי
הַזָּקֵן
עֲמִיתָם
וְעֵד עִנּוּיֵי
הַמָּשִׁיחַ
וְגַם־חָבֵר
לַכָּבוֹד
הֶעָתִיד
לְהִגָּלוֹת׃ |
2.
Shepherd the flocklet of God among you, supervising, not of compulsion, but
voluntarily, according to God; nor yet avariciously, but eagerly;" |
2.
feed the flock of God that has been committed to you and perform [it]
spiritually, not by necessity, but willingly, not for corrupt profits, but
from your whole heart, |
2.
ποιμάνατε τὸ ἐν
ὑμῖν ποίμνιον
τοῦ Θεοῦ, ἐπισκοποῦντες
μὴ ἀναγκαστῶς,
ἀλλ᾽ ἑκουσίως·
μηδὲ αἰσχροκερδῶς,
ἀλλὰ προθύμως, |
2 רְעוּ
אֶת־עֵדֶר
הָאֱלֹהִים
אֲשֶׁר
תַּחַת יֶדְכֶם
וְהַשְׁגִּיחוּ
עֲלֵיהֶם
לֹא בְאֹנֶס
כִּי
אִם־בִּנְדָבָה
כִּרְצוֹן
אֱלֹהִים
וְלֹא עֵקֶב
בֶּצַע רָע
כִּי
אִם־בְּנֶפֶשׁ
חֲפֵצָה׃ |
3.
nor yet as lording it over the allotments, but becoming models for the
flocklet, |
3.
You should not be as lords of the flock, but as a good example for
them, |
3.
μηδ᾽ ὡς
κατακυριεύοντες
τῶν κλήρων, ἀλλὰ
τύποι γινόμενοι
τοῦ ποιμνίου. |
3 אַף־לֹא
כְּרוֹדָנִים
בְּנַחֲלַת
יְהֹוָה
כִּי
אִם־לִהְיוֹת
מוֹפֵת
לַצֹּאן׃ |
4.
and, when the Chief Shepherd is manifested, you shall be requited with an
unfading wreath of glory." |
4.
so that when the chief of the shepherds is revealed, you will receive
a crown of glory from him that will not fade. |
4.
καὶ φανερωθέντος
τοῦ ἀρχιποίμενος
κομιεῖσθε τὸν ἀμαράντινον
τῆς δόξης στέφανον. |
4 וּבְהוֹפָעַת
שַׂר
הָרֹעִים
תִּשְׂאוּ
עֲטֶרֶת
הַכָּבוֹד אֲשֶׁר
לֹא תִבֹּל׃ |
|
|
|
|
Hakhams
Rendition
1.
Elders (Zqenim) who [are] among you, I exhort (strengthen), who
[am] a fellow elder (Zaqen), and [a] witness of Messiahs sufferings, who also
of the glory about to be progressively unveiled [am a] partaker:
2.
Shepherd the little flock of God among you, exercising oversight, not by
compulsion, but willingly; not [greedily] for dishonest gain, but [rather]
readily [with passion];
3.
Not as exercising [despotic] lordship over [your] possessions, but [rather
progressively] becoming role models for the flock.
4.
And at the manifestation of the chief Shepherd, you will receive the unfading
crown of glory.
Commentary
v.1 Elders (Zqenim)
who [are] among you, I exhort (strengthen), [who [am] a fellow elder
(Zaqen), and [a] witness of Messiahs sufferings, who also of the glory about
to be progressively unveiled [am a] partaker]: - The Jewish
Encyclopedia[5]
describes the Greek term used here: Presbyter, and normally translated as
Elder as:
From the time of Moses down to the Talmudic period
the "zeḳenim" (elders) are mentioned as constituting a regular
communal organization, occasionally under the Greek name Gerusia. But the term
"presbyter"
(πρεσβύτερος) is found
nowhere before the beginnings of Christianity, though it must have been current
before that time, for the Christian institution of the presbyters was
undoubtedly taken directly from Judaism (Grδtz, "Gesch." 3d ed., iv.
80). In a list of officials of a Jewish community in Cilicia, archisynagogues,
priests (ἱερεύς = "kohen"), presbyters
("zeḳenim"), and "azanites" ("ḥazzanim")
are mentioned, and if the source (Epiphanius, "Hζres." xxx. 4) gives
the sequence correctly, the presbyters were actually officials, like the
azanites, and did not hold merely honorary offices in the community.
Their status, therefore, would correspond
approximately to the position which presbyters occupy in the Christian Church.
It may be assumed, however, that they stood in rank next to the
archisynagogues, with whom elsewhere they are actually identified ("Codex
Theodosianus," xvi. 8, 14"archisynagogi sive presbyteri
Judζorum"). In another passage (ib. xvi. 8, 2) they are identified with
the patriarchs; in another (ib. xvi. 8, 13) the following sequence occurs:
archisynagogue, patriarch, presbyter; finally ("Justiniani Novellζ,"
cxlvi., § 1), they are ranked with the "archipherecites" and
teachers. "Presbyter" corresponds to the Latin "seniores"
("Codex Justiniani," i. 9, 15). Thus it appears that there is no uniformity
even in the official designations.
However
in another article under the heading Community, Organization of the
Same Encyclopedia[6]
states:
The governing board was subject to the
"dayyan" (judge, also called "ḥakam," or "zaḳen"),
who was ordained by the nasi or exilarch, and was the final authority on
ritual, civil, and political questions. He decided unaided in money matters
(without being obliged to make restitution in case of an error of judgment),
where otherwise three lay judges were required. Criminal cases were decided
only by three scholars of standing (), who were usually
elected for life to insure impartiality and respect. They did not, in general,
draw a salary, but when their entire time was devoted to the affairs of the
community, they might receive means sufficient for a bare subsistence. They had
supervision over all religious and political affairs. Those who had been
ordained at Babylon were called "rabbonim"; those ordained in
Palestine were called "rabbis." The title of "ḥaber"
(associate) was bestowed upon a person who had rendered special services to the
community. He was considered in many cases as arbitrator. A community consisting
of more than ten members was a synagogal community, and was obliged to secure a
synagogue, the judicial and outer affairs of which were in the hands of a
committee elected from the members of the governing board. It was not
permissible to sell or exchange the synagogue, except in cases of extreme
necessity, nor could the old synagogue be pulled down before the new one was
built. Affairs pertaining to the ritual and liturgy were in the hands of the
archisynagogue. (This term when applied to a woman, as in old Roman
inscriptions, meant, no doubt, merely the president of a woman's philanthropic
society, like the "parnesessa" at Rome in the sixteenth century.) The
archisynagogue was especially honored, his office being for life and sometimes
hereditary. In the Diaspora there were honorary titles, such as
"fathers," or "mothers, of the synagogue"; thus, the title
of "mater synagogζ" or "pateressa" was conferred upon Dona
Gracia Mendesia. The "rosh ha-keneset" (archisynagogue) was
subordinate to the "ḥazzan ha-keneset," whose orders were
authoritative in synagogal and in general matters; he was also executor of the
punishments decreed by the court, and performed the functions of the later
"shammash," who is otherwise called
("the messenger of the court") in the Talmud and by the
Geonim.
It
is clear then, that the Hebrew term Zaken (Pl. Zakenim) translated into Greek
as either Presbuteroi (πρεσβντεροι)
or Gerontoes (γέροντοες), and
translated to English as Elder/s became a general term for the seven leaders
of the congregation/community, and more specifically to the persons occupying the
bench of three in a Bet Din. Notice that in the last article, the words Dayan
(Judge), Hakham (Rabbi), and Zaken are all synonymous terms. However for
the sake of peace and simplicity we should say that any of the ten men leading
a Jewish congregation/community receive the title of Zaken or Elder and it
is in this sense that the title should be understood here in 1 Tsefet (Peter)
5:1.
I
exhort The
English word Exhortation comes
from the Latin exhortationem, from the verb exhortari, from ex
meaning "thoroughly" + hortari meaning "encourage, urge,
fortify, strengthen." The Greek here: PARAKALO has the same meaning and
function. Note also, that the associated Greek word PARAKLITOS means
comforter, advocate, strengthener. The word is masterly used here to point to
the pericopes reading during the seven Sabbaths of
Consolation/Comfort/Strengthening.
With
regard to the last phrase of this verse: who [am] a fellow elder (Hakham),
and [a] witness of Messiahs sufferings, who also of the glory about to be
progressively unveiled [am a] partaker: are found in some Bibles in
brackets since there is among some Christian Scholars great doubts that this
clause was in the original version of this work (cf. Beare F. W., 1970, p. 188[7];
& Elliot, J.H, 2000, p. 817[8]).
However, others (cf. Jobes K.H., 2009, pp. 300-301[9])
propose that this clause is very much part of this pericope and refer to
previous pericopes to adduce evidence for retaining this clause as authentic. I
propose that this clause should be retained, since the most important verbal
tally between this pericope and the readings from the Hebrew Bible for this
Shabbat is based on a word that appears in this disputed clause i.e. the term μάρτυς (MARTUS Strongs # G3144),
and meaning witness found in 1 Peter 5:1 and the Hebrew word in Isaiah 8:2 עֵדִים (Eidim
pl.
from the sing. Eid Strongs # H5707), and meaning witness/testimony.
It is therefore, with this in mind that we are inclined very much to state that
this clause figured most probably in the original of this text.
At
the same time we want to point out, that with the rapid expansion of Nazarean
Judaism at this point in time, and congregations appearing all over the Roman
Empire, at most, the Nazarean Hakhamim trained by the Master and resident in
Jerusalem and in Babylon, had at best enough time to prepare Paqidim to lead
collegiately the congregations, but there was not enough time to have trained top
Torah Scholars in such a quantity and quality as to be presiding in local Batei
Din over these congregations. That the so called Apostles must have trained in
fact great Torah Scholars is not in dispute, what is questionable though, is
that they had prepared enough Torah Scholars to maintain the viability and
continuity of Nazarean Judaism. In fact, this is in our view one of the critical
problems of the rapid expansion of Nazarean Judaism in the first and second
centuries. This fact is clearly corroborated in the literature of the so called
Christian early Church Fathers of the third and fourth centuries.
2.
Shepherd the little flock of God among you, exercising oversight, not by
compulsion, but willingly; not [greedily] for dishonest gain, but [rather]
readily [with passion];- This verse seems to me to be directed not only to
the leadership of the various congregations in Asia Minor and Babylonia, but
also betrays in my view that Hakham Tsefet is addressing a Jewish leadership
presiding over these Nazarean Jewish converts. To understand this point one
needs to have spent some years in a Jewish Orthodox milieu. When a Jewish Torah
Scholar is asked to instruct a group of Gentiles, he is very much tempted in
the process to bring about the level of learning discipline amongst Torah
Observant Orthodox Jews to the group of Gentiles before him. Soon he realizes
that such is only achievable over a long period time, as Gentiles are not used
to long hours of study of complex materials. Patience may brittle, and he may
succumb to the proposition of enforcing some harsh disciplinary methods. On the
other hand, the Torah Scholar may soon feel like he has been conscripted to
teaching Gentiles, and would rather prefer to return to his own and teach his
own people who are accustomed to the rigors of Torah Study in-depth. With
regards to the first problem Hakham Tsefet counsels: Not as exercising [despotic]
lordship over [your] possessions, but [rather progressively] becoming role
models for the flock. And with regards to the second problem he continues:
Shepherd the little flock of God among you, exercising oversight not by
compulsion, but willingly.
Again
a Torah Scholar is a well trained, highly skilled, multifaceted individual and
would have no problem in retraining for another profession and earn a high
salary. To this Hakham Tsefet answers: not [greedily] for dishonest
gain. On the other hand, teaching Torah to recent Jewish converts, is not
an easy thing to do, and great discouragement for a Torah Scholar is meat on
every step of the road in one form or another. To this problem Hakham Tsefet
answers: but [rather] readily [with passion]. Breaking
years of prejudice, wrong teaching, erroneous doctrine, old foreign cultural
patterns and ways of thinking, bad habits and wrong practices is not easy. This
is why converts who apply themselves to regular in-depth Torah study have great
merit accumulated for them, since I as a born Jew, was born into this way of
life. Nevertheless, taking a Torah Scholar to train converts is very much like
taking a Professor at a good University in the U.S. and sending him to teach
primary school in a foreign country which has a different culture, and a
different language. As you can see all the problems that I have mentioned above
will emerge rather quickly.
On
the other hand, if one is not a Torah Scholar (i.e. a Hakham) one must be
perpetually cognizant of the wise counsel of our Sages: Wander
to a place of Torah, and do not say that it [the Torah] will come after you or
that your associates will establish you in the possession of it (Pirqe
Abot IV:13)!
4.
And at the manifestation of the chief Shepherd, you will receive the unfading
crown of glory. This
goes along with what I explained about the heroic efforts of a convert to
Judaism who faithfully and diligently goes on to study Torah in-depth and becomes
a Torah Scholar him/herself, as well as to the Jewish Torah Scholar who armed
with much patience and diligence brings to convert to Judaism to become a Torah
Scholar. The Greek words here are τὸν (TON) ἀμαράντινον
(AMARANTINON) τῆς (TIS) δόξης (DOXIS)
στέφανον (STEPHANON), and literally:
the Amaranth wreath or glory. Jobes[10]
states that:
AMARANTION
refers to the quality of the amaranth flower, a red blossom whose color is
unfading. The crown here is an image well-known to the first-century
Greco-Roman world, for a wreath of leaves worn on the head was commonly awarded
to those who won athletic competitions. A similar wreath, but made of gold, was
frequently given as the reward for civic benefactors (cf. Llewelyn[11]).
Perhaps
in todays world the imagery of a doctoral cap and gown the symbols of
scholarship and intensive work would be more appropriate.
Our
Torah Seder in Vayiqra 13:29, states: If a man or a woman has a lesion on the head
And we learn about the various
examinations of the priest to determine whether the lesion is tzara'ath (miraculous
leprosy). I
believe that in this pericope Hakham Tsefet is trying to urge the leadership, i.e. the head of the local congregation/community to realize that a defective
collegiate leadership of the congregation has great and severe ramifications. Therefore
he proposes the strengthening of the collegiate leadership in this appropriate
time of strenthening, so that all the members of the community can benefit from a great
cohesive and learned leadership.
However, the most significant
verbal tally, according to Dr. Elisheba bat Sarah between this pericope and the
ordinary Ashlamatah of Isaiah 7:20 8:3 + 9:6 is the term μάρτυς (MARTUS Strongs # G3144),
and meaning witness found in 1 Peter 5:1 and the Hebrew word in Isaiah 8:2 עֵדִים (Eidim
pl.
from the sing. Eid Strongs # H5707), and meaning witness/testimony.
As we remarked in v.1 this verbal tally points to the fact that the last clause
of v.1 was in the original of this Epistle.
Correlations
By H.H. Rosh Paqid Adon Hillel
ben David &
Giberet Dr. Elisheba bat Sarah
Vayikra (Leviticus) 13:29-59
Tehillim (Psalm) 78:32-39
Yeshayahu (Isaiah) 7:20 8:3 +
9:6
Yeshayahu (Isaiah) 54:1-10
1 Tsefet (Peter) 5:1-4
The
verbal tally between the Torah portion and the Psalm are:
Days
- יום,
Strongs number 03117.
The
verbal tallies between the Torah portion and the Ashlamata are:
Man
- איש,
Strongs number 0376.
Head
- ראש,
Strongs number 07218.
Beard
- זקן,
Strongs number 02206.
Priest
- כהן,
Strongs number 03548.
Hair
- שער,
Strongs number 08181.
The
verbal tally between the Torah portion and the Special Ashlamata are:
Woman
- אשה,
Strongs number 0802.
Vayikra
13:29-31
If a man <0376> or woman <0802> have a plague <05061> upon
the head <07218> or the beard <02206>;
30 Then the priest <03548> shall see
<07200> (8804) the plague <05061>: and, behold, if it be in sight
<04758> deeper <06013> than the skin <05785>; and there be in
it a yellow <06669> thin <01851> hair <08181>; then the
priest <03548> shall pronounce him unclean <02930> (8765): it is a
dry scall <05424>, even a leprosy <06883> upon the head
<07218> or beard <02206>.
31 And if the priest <03548> look
<07200> (8799) on the plague <05061> of the scall <05424>,
and, behold, it be not in sight <04758> deeper <06013> than the
skin <05785>, and that there is no black <07838> hair <08181>
in it; then the priest <03548> shall shut <05462> (8689) up him
that hath the plague <05061> of the scall <05424> seven
<07651> days <03117>:
Tehillim
(Psalm) 78:33 Therefore their days <03117> did he
consume in vanity, and their years in trouble.
Yeshayahu
(Isaiah) 7:20-21
In the same day shall the Lord shave with a razor that is hired, namely, by
them beyond the river, by the king of Assyria, the head <07218>, and the
hair <08181> of the feet: and it shall also consume the beard
<02206>.
21
And it shall come to pass in that day, that a man <0376> shall nourish a
young cow, and two sheep;
Yeshayahu
(Isaiah) 8:2
And I took unto me faithful witnesses to record, Uriah the priest
<03548>, and Zechariah the son of Jeberechiah.
Yeshayahu
(Isaiah) 54:6 For the LORD hath called thee as a woman
<0802> forsaken and grieved in spirit, and a wife <0802> of youth,
when thou wast refused, saith thy God.
Hebrew:
Hebrew |
English |
Torah Seder Lev. 13:29-59 |
Psalms Ps 78:32-39 |
Ashlamatah Is. 7:20 8:3 + 9:6 |
Special Ashlamatah Is. 54:1-10 |
אִישׁ |
man |
Le 13.29 |
Is 7.21 |
||
אִיתִיאֵל |
this |
Ps 78.32 |
Is 54.9 |
||
אֱלֹהִים |
GOD |
Ps 78.35 |
Is 54.6 |
||
אִם |
if, when |
Le 13.35 |
Ps 78.34 |
||
אֶרֶץ |
earth, land |
Is 7.22s |
Is 54.5 |
||
אִשָּׁה |
woman, wife |
Le 13.29 |
Is 54.6 |
||
אֲשֶׁר |
who, which, where |
Le 13.45 |
Is 7.23 |
Is 54.9 |
|
בְּרִית |
covenant |
Ps 78.37 |
Is 54.10 |
||
בָּשָׂר |
body, flesh |
Le 13.38 |
Ps 78.39 |
||
גָּאַל |
redeemer |
Ps 78.35 |
Is 54.5 |
||
גָּלַח |
shaved |
Le 13.33 |
Is 7.20 |
||
הָיָה |
has, become |
Le 13.29 |
Is 7.23 |
||
הַר |
mountain |
Is 7.25 |
Is 54.10 |
||
זָכַר |
remembered |
Ps 78.35 |
Is 54.4 |
||
זָקָן |
beard |
Le 13.29 |
Is 7.20 |
||
יוֹם |
day |
Le 13.31 |
Ps 78.33 |
Is 7.21 |
Is 54.9 |
יָשַׁב |
shall live, resettle |
Le 13.46 |
Is 54.3 |
||
כִּי |
if, because when |
Le 13.29 |
Is 7.24 |
Is 54.6 |
|
כֹּל |
all |
Le 13.46 |
Ps 78.32 |
Is 7.22 |
Is 54.5 |
לֹה |
no, nor |
Le 13.32 |
Ps 78.37 |
Is 54.1 |
|
מִנִּי |
than, because, nor |
Le 13.30 |
Is 7.22 |
Is 54.9 |
|
מָקוֹם |
place |
Is 7.23 |
Is 54.2 |
||
עוֹד |
again, still |
Le 13.57 |
Ps 78.32 |
Is 54.9 |
|
פָּנֶה |
front, face |
Le 13.44 |
Is 54.8 |
||
קָרָא |
cry, called |
Le 13.45 |
Is 54.5 |
||
רֹאשׁ |
head |
Le 13.29 |
Is 7.20 |
||
רוּחַ |
spirit, wind |
Ps 78.39 |
Is 54.6 |
||
שֵׂעָר |
hair |
Le 13.29 |
Is 7.20 |
||
hf'[' |
produced, Maker |
Is 7.22 |
Is 54.5 |
Greek:
Greek |
English |
Torah Seder Lev. 13:29-59 |
Psalms Ps 78:32-39 |
Ashlamatah Is. 7:20 8:3+9:6 |
Special Ashlamatah Is. 54:1-10 |
Nazarean Codicil 1 Pe 5:1-4 |
θεός |
GOD |
Ps 78.34 |
Is 9.6 |
Is 54.5 |
1 Pe 5.2 |
|
μάρτυς |
witness |
Is 8.2 |
1 Pe 5.1 |
Mishnah Pirke
Abot: IV:13
Rabbi Nehorai said: Wander to a place
of Torah, and do not say that it [the Torah] will come after you or that your
associates will establish you in the possession of it; and do not depend on
your own understanding.
Rabbi Yannai said: It is not in our
power to explain either the prosperity of the wicked or the afflictions of the
righteous. Rabbi Mattya ben Harash said: Be first in greeting all men; and be
rather a tail to lions than a head to foxes.
Abarbanel
on Pirke Abot
By:
Abraham Chill
Sepher
Hermon Press, Inc. 1991
ISBN
0-87203-135-7
(pp.
269-274)
Abarbanel
calls our attention to the fact that, according to one opinion in the Talmud,
the real name of Rabbi Nehorai was Elazar ben Arokh. He was called Nehorai
because the translation of this Aramaic name is "light" - the
profundity of Rabbi Elazar ben Arokh's knowledge was a light unto all the
scholars of his period.
According
to Abarbanel, Rabbi Shimon in the previous Mishnah, dealing with the three
crowns, was not overly expansive regarding the crown of Torah, which is the
most important of the three. Because of this, Rabbi Nehorai felt impelled to
advocate that a person should, if necessary, exile himself to a place where the
study of Torah is preeminent. It is more prudent for one to be in a strange
country and in a strange environment where the resounding voice of Torah is
heard, than to be an important personality in one's own bailiwick without a
Torah atmosphere.
Rabbi
Nehorai continues: There are three instances when one might be tempted to
disregard this advice. The first is when a person is aware that by his genetic
make-up he has inherited the scholarly qualities of his forebears and there is
thus no need for him to work hard at acquiring wisdom, since he knows it will,
by nature, come to him easily. Such a person relies on the famous Aggadic
premise that when the first sperm impregnates the woman, it is announced in
Heaven whether the child created will be wise or ignorant. Similarly, a person may
see from his horoscope, or have been told, that the astrological conditions at
his birth were such that he is destined to be a wise man. To such a person
Rabbi Nehorai advises: Do not depend too much on your own calculations. You may
have mistaken the whole concept of genetics. Unless you yourself toil and sweat
to acquire Torah wisdom, you will never know the meaning of scholarship.
The
second instance: It is always tempting to avoid the discomfort involved in
scholarly endeavour by adopting the attitude, "Let other scholars undergo
the hardship of search, research and study and I will benefit from their
accomplishments." However, Rabbi Nehorai points out that this is the wrong
attitude because they who have heard the wisdom from the masters themselves are
at an advantage over the one who only benefitted from a secondary source. This
was true at Mt. Sinai when the Children of Israel refused to listen to the
proclamation of the Ten Commandments from Moshe, but insisted, "Everything
that the Lord will say, we shall do" (Exodus 24:7).
The
third instance concerns the scholar who arrogantly assumes that he can sit at
home and devote himself to. study, and that there is no need for him to travel
to the academies. What this person does not understand is that the progress and
advancement that a scholar makes can be greatly improved by discussion,
argument and debate with his colleagues.
Another
interpretation by Abarbanel, more in keeping with that of Rashi, sees in Rabbi
Nehorai's dictum a call for the scholar not only to seek the venues of Torah
study but, if necessary, to experience physical and mental pain in order to
live in a pure Torah environment. In this interpretation, the main thrust of
Rabbi Nehorai is on the importance of the proper environment.
The
Talmud relates (Shabbat 147b) that Rabbi Elazar ben Arokh (whom we identified above
as Rabbi Nehorai of this Mishnah) once came to a strange city and immersed
himself in the joys of the flesh. In a short time he forgot all his learning to
the extent that he could not even read a verse from the Torah correctly. This,
concerning the man whom Rabbi Yohanan ben Zakkai (Chapter II, Mishnah 7)
thought to be superior to all the other sages of Israel put together! His
colleagues realized the gravity of the situation and prayed for him and his memory
was restored. This is what an environment devoid of Torah can cause. Abarbanel
believes that this theme is the basis for the Torah's call to the Jew to travel
three times a year to Jerusalem, from whatever outpost he lived in, to
celebrate the three major festivals. In that way, he would be sure to be in
proximity to the Sanhedrin, the priests and the learned, and benefit from the
spiritual and academic environment.
Rabbi
Yannai stood aghast at the declaration of Rabbi Nehorai and asked, "Is
this the life of the Torah student and is this his reward?" The wicked/Lawless
have no need to experience these hardships to achieve their ends, why should
this be the lot of the Torah personality? Rabbi Yannai therefore argues that in
reality we do not know for certain that the lifestyle of the wicked/Lawless is
really desirable or that the trials of the Torah student are really
undesirable. Who knows the real truths of what is a good life and what is a bad
life? Hence, Rabbi Yannai advocates that the purpose and motive for Torah study
should not be centred around the lifestyle but, rather, to attain an end that
in itself is good.
Abarbanel
augments this line of thinking by referring us to Moshe who, also, was
confounded by this problem and entreated God, "Please teach me Your
ways" (Exodus 33: 13). With marked sarcasm, Abarbanel attacks the whole
concept of righteous/generous and wicked/Lawless in order to discourage us from
delving too deeply into this subject. He speculates that it is very possible
that the one whom we believe to be truly righteous/generous is not really as
pious as we thought, and that the sinner is indeed not as wicked/Lawless as we
presumed. Who knows the actual truth?
The
last Sage in this Mishnah, Rabbi Mattya ben Harash accepts the premise of Rabbi
Nehorai that the Scholar must expect to experience hardships. However, he
offers two ways in which to overcome the difficulties a Scholar will meet when
he goes to a strange place to study Torah. The Scholar must learn to be
social-minded and relate to society in a friendly manner. He must greet
everyone with kindness and then society will repay him. Secondly, he should
assume the attitude that it is preferable to be the tail of a lion than the
head of a fox, because a lion raises his tail towards his head while a fox
droops its head towards its tail. In other words, even if the Scholar is the
junior of a distinguished group, he can look forward to elevating himself to a
position of leadership. If, however, he attaches himself to an inferior group,
he may be the head, but he cannot go any higher. This is illustrated by the
seating arrangement at the Sanhedrin in Jerusalem (Sanhedrin 37a): The seventy
members of the Sanhedrin sat in rows. The illustrious ones occupied the front
seats, the freshmen sat in the back seats. When a member of the front section
died, the one who was next in line in the second row moved forward to occupy
his position in front row. Joshua's career also illustrates this principle. He
served as the tail of the two great lions, Moshe and Aaron, and after they died
he was chosen for the leadership.
Miscellaneous
Interpretations
Rabbenu Yonah,
commenting on Rabbi Nehorai's admonition that one should wander to a Torah
center, stresses the notion that nothing should be allowed to prevent the
pursuit of Torah study, even if the student has to wander to a Yeshivah. A
budding scholar will never realize his potential if he assumes the attitude
that he will remain comfortable in the environment of his own community and
will wait until the full-fledged scholars return, and they will teach him. A
man must become actively involved himself in Torah study in order to attain
some degree of success. Moreover, when you do move to a center of learning, do not
become egoistic, but be patient in following the instructions of the master.
Rabbi Yannai draws us into the age-old question
regarding the tranquil life of the wicked/Lawless as contrasted with the
suffering of the righteous/generous. Rabbenu Yonah comes straight to the point:
This is one area in Jewish theology where the poverty of our wisdom cannot
provide us with an adequate answer. This is what Jeremiah (12:1) meant,
"You will win, O Lord, if I make claim against You, yet I will present
charges against You: why does the way of the wicked prosper... ?"
Undoubtedly, Rabbi Mattya, in speaking of the lion and
the fox was referring to the major scholar and the minor scholar. He urges us
to be content with being on the lowest rung of disciples in the academy of a
scholastic luminary rather than to seek to be prominent in an academy of less
distinction. We can always learn from those who are superior to us; never from
a coterie of inferior students. This is what the sages meant, "He who was
a member of a minor Sanhedrin could later be appointed to membership in the
Great Sanhedrin" (Sanhedrin 37a).
Rabbi Almosnino: Rabbi
Nehorai's suggestion that one should wander to a place of Torah does not mean a
place where several great scholars teach. This is not sufficient. What Rabbi
Nehorai meant was a city where the atmosphere, surroundings and community
character is pervaded by Torah. Under these conditions, the wanderer cannot
help but be submerged in Torah studies.
He rejects outright the common interpretation of Rabbi
Mattya's axiom concerning the lion and the fox. He believes to be at the head
of the foxes or the lions is not productive. In neither situation can a scholar
continue to develop and elevate himself to a higher level: Even if he is the
head of great scholars, he will teach and not study; he will not progress but
will remain as he is. The ideal choice is to be the lowliest among lions - the
lowliest among great scholars from whom he can still acquire more Torah
knowledge.
An Anonymous View: When one
is the tail of a lion, he is still considered a part of the lion; the head of a
fox is still considered a fox.
Rashbatz:
According to one tradition, Rabbi Nehorai's real name was Rabbi Meir. Nehorai,
the Aramaic, and Meir, the Hebrew word, both mean "to enlighten."
This sage illuminated the Halakhah to all the scholars.
Concerning Rabbi Yannai's statement about the
theological problem of the injustice of the tranquility of the wicked/Lawless
and the suffering of the righteous/generous, Rashbatz suggests that the reading
should be as follows: It is most difficult to fathom the untroubled life of the
sinners because their wickedness/Lawlessness is apparent to all. Why should
they have a good life? It is even more difficult to understand the suffering of
the righteous/generous, although it should come as no surprise to us that no
person born of woman can avoid sin. We still do not understand why his condition
is so depressing.
Pertaining to the dicta of Rabbi Mattya, Rashbatz
merely repeats what others have said, adding nothing new of his own. He is
accustomed to giving a brief biographical sketch of the rabbis of these Mishnayot,
and he does the same for Rabbi Mattya. It is told that the latter resolved
never to look at strange women. Satan, however, put him to the test and Rabbi
Mattyah felt himself weakening. Whereupon he took red-hot nails and gorged his
own eyes out. God became witness to this phenomenal dedication to purity of
thought and sent the angel Raphael to heal him, and promised not to tempt him
again.
Midrash Shemuel: Why did
Rabbi Nehorai employ the word goleh (to go into exile), the same
term used by the Torah for the criminal who seeks a city of refuge. Just as the
criminal will hastily escape the scene of the crime to find his peace elsewhere,
so must the Jew beat a rapid retreat from a non-Torah environment and make his
escape to a Torah environment. He may not say, "I will reside in this
nonconformist atmosphere and I will not be affected because I come from a long
line of scholars." He will be affected.
Another view: If one is living in a boorish community,
but in splendid comfort, he should wander, even in great poverty, to a place of
Torah. He should not justify staying in his place by arguing that he can easily
afford to bring in a master to teach him privately. The competitive spirit
among peers is preferable to lectures by a master.
Midrash Shemuel analyzes Rabbi Yannai's maxim and
reflects that somehow or other God in His omniscience realizes that tranquility
for the Jew is not productive. The Jew needs, at times, to experience an
uncomfortable situation which will galvanize him to more religiosity and Torah
study. Neither is the Jew ever worthy of extreme penalties. He is too honorable
for that. Therefore, says Midrash Shemuel, it is difficult to understand God's
ways.
In an attempt to explain Rabbi Yannai psychologically,
Midrash Shemuel muses that a person can be congenitally and intrinsically of a
criminal bent. There is very little that he can do about it. If he does do
something right, he should be credited with praise and reward to counterbalance
all of his transgressions. The same line of reasoning is true of the person who
is naturally good. When he commits a wrong he should be condemned as a
counterbalance to his goodness.
Referring to Rabbi Mattya's statement about greeting
one's fellow-man, Midrash Shemuel sees it as just a simple piece of advise: If
a person wishes to become popular, let him not wait for the other to take the
initiative in a friendly gesture, but let him make the first move.
With regard to the last part of the maxim, Midrash
Shemuel urges us not to adopt the attitude that if we do not possess the
talents to be the head of lions, it is preferable withdraw from the occupation
entirely and occupy ourselves with business, rather than become a tail to
foxes. Torah study does not mean that one must become an outstanding scholar;
studying Torah itself is a mitzvah!
Rabbi Moshe Alshakhar: We were
taught that there is a crown of Torah. Where there is royalty there is wealth,
influence and honor. If one heard that there were riches in a far distant land
to be given to anyone who arrived there, would he not hasten over land and sea
to be the first to receive the prize. In that light, Rabbi Nehorai urges
us to pursue the spiritual riches of the Torah even if we must wander to
acquire them.
What Say the
Nazarean Hakhamim?
Heb
10:24
And let us consider one another for the stirring up (provoking) of love and of
good works,
Heb
10:25
not forsaking the assembling of ourselves, just as is the custom for some, but
exhorting (strengthening) one another, and all the more as you see the Day
drawing near.
2Ti
2:15 Be
diligent to show yourself approved unto God, a worker unashamed, rightly
dividing the word of truth.
2Ti
2:16 But shun profane and empty babblings; for they will advance to more
ungodliness.
Rom 12:1 Therefore, brothers,
I exhort you through the mercies of God, to present your bodies a living
sacrifice, holy, well pleasing to God, which is your intelligent service.
Rom 12:2 And do not pattern
yourselves after this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind,
that you may prove what is that good and well pleasing and perfect will of God.
Rom 12:3 For I say, through the
grace given to me, to everyone who is among you, not to think of himself too
highly, beyond what you should think, but to think soberly, as God has imparted
to each one a measure of faith.
Rom 12:4 For just as we have many
members in one body, but all the members do not have the same function,
Rom 12:5 so we, being many,
are one body in Messiah, and individually members of one another.
Rom 12:6 Having then gifts differing
according to the Chessed having been given to us, let us use them: whether
prophecy, let us prophecy according to the proportion of faith;
Rom 12:7 whether service, let us
use it in our service; whether teaching; in the teaching;
Rom 12:8 whether strengthening,
in the strengthening [of others]; whether sharing, with simplicity; whether
leading, with diligence; whether showing mercy, with cheerfulness.
Rom 12:9 Let love be without
hypocrisy. Abhor that which is evil. Cling to that which is good.
Rom 12:10 Be warmly affectionate
to one another with brotherly love, in honor preferring one another;
Rom 12:11 not lagging in
diligence, fervent in spirit, serving the Lord;
Rom 12:12 rejoicing in hope,
enduring in tribulation, continuing steadfastly in prayer;
Rom 12:13 sharing in the needs of
the Tsadiqim, pursuing hospitality.
Rom 12:14 Bless those that
persecute you; bless and do not curse.
Rom 12:15 Rejoice with those that
rejoice, and weep with those that weep.
Rom 12:16 Be of the same mind
toward one another. Not minding the high things, but associating with the
humble. Do not become wise in your own opinion.
Rom 12:17 Repay no one evil for
evil; providing that which is good before all men.
Rom 12:18 If possible, as much as
depends on you, keeping peace with all men.
Rom 12:19 Beloved, do not avenge
yourselves, but give place to wrath; for it is written, "Vengeance is
Mine, I will repay," says the Lord.
Rom 12:20 Therefore "If your
enemy should hunger, feed him; if he should thirst, give him drink; for by
doing this you will heap coals of fire upon his head."
Rom 12:21 Do not be overcome by
evil, but overcome evil with good.
Some
Questions to Ponder:
1.
From all the readings for this
Shabbat, what verse or verses touched your heart and fired your imagination?
2.
What are the main topics and
divisions of the Torah Seder for this Shabbat?
3.
What questions were asked of
Rashi regarding Vayiqra 13:29?
4.
What questions were asked of
Rashi regarding Vayiqra 13:42?
5.
What questions were asked of
Rashi regarding Vayiqra 13:46?
6.
What questions were asked of
Rashi regarding Vayiqra 13:55?
7.
What questions were asked of
Rashi regarding Vayiqra 13:58?
8.
What Peshat Hermeneutical
principle does Rashi employ in answering a question raised with regards to the
contents of Vayiqra 13:44?
9.
What important principle can we
deduce from Rashis explanation of Vayiqra 13:46?
10.
Where in the readings for this
Shabbat is it insinuated that we are in a period of consolation/strengthening
and returning to G-d?
11.
How is the Torah Seder related to
our reading of Psalm 78:32-39 both by verbal tally and thematically?
12.
How is the Torah Seder related
both by verbal tally and thematically to our Ashlamatah of 7:20ff?
13.
How is the Torah Seder related
both by verbal tally and thematically to our Special Ashlamatah of Isaiah 54:1-10?
14.
How is the reading of 1 Tsefet
5:1-4 related to each of the readings for this Shabbat?
15.
What important overall principles
are taught in 1 Tsefet 5:1-4?
16.
How is Pirqe Abot IV:13 related
to our readings for this Shabbat?
17.
How is Vayiqra 13:29-30 related
to Varyiqra 13:58-59?
18.
In your opinion, and taking into
consideration all of the above readings for this Sabbath, what is the prophetic
message for this week?
Next Shabbat
(Ellul 18, 5770):
Shabbat Nachamu
6
6th
of 7 Sabbaths of the Consolation of Yisrael
Shabbat |
Torah Reading: |
Weekday Torah Reading: |
הַמְּצֹרָע |
|
|
HaMtsorα |
Reader 1 Vayiqra 14:1-4 |
Reader 1 Vayiqra 14:33-35 |
of the lepper |
Reader 2 Vayiqra 14:5-8 |
Reader 2 Vayiqra 14:36-38 |
del
leproso |
Reader 3 Vayiqra 14:9-11 |
Reader 3 Vayiqra 14:39-42 |
Vayiqra (Leviticus) 14:1-32 |
Reader 4 Vayiqra 14:12-16 |
|
Ashlamatah: Isaiah
57:17-19 + 58:8-14 |
Reader 5 Vayiqra 14:17-20 |
|
Special: Isaiah 60:1-22
|
Reader 6 Vayiqra 14:21-23 |
Reader 1 Vayiqra 14:33-35 |
Psalm 78:40-55 |
Reader 7 Vayiqra 14:24-32 |
Reader 2 Vayiqra 14:36-38 |
Pirqe Abot
IV:14 |
Maftir:
Vayiqra 14:30-32 |
Reader 3 Vayiqra 14:39-42 |
N.C.: I Tsefet (Peter) 5:5- |
Isaiah
60:1-22 |
|
Coming Special
Days:
Rosh HaShanah Jewish
New Year
Tishri 1-2
Evening
Wednesday September the 8th Friday Evening September the 10th
For further study see:
http://www.betemunah.org/teruah.html; http://www.betemunah.org/shofar.html;
http://www.betemunah.org/knowday.html; & http://www.betemunah.org/awesome.html
Shalom
Shabbat !
Hakham
Dr. Yosef ben Haggai
Rosh
Paqid Adon Hillel ben David
Dr. Adon Eliyahu ben Abraham
[1] CLV
(Concordant Literal Version) as found in Rick Meyers (2009) E-Sword v.
9.5.1 - http://www.e-sword.net/downloads.html
[2] Magiera, J.M. (2009),
Aramaic Peshitta New Testament: Vertical Interlinear, Light of the Word
Ministry, Vol. III.
[3] Greek New
Testament (Majority Text) as found in Rick Meyers (2009) E-Sword v. 9.5.1 -
http://www.e-sword.net/downloads.html
[4] Delitzsch, http://www.kirjasilta.net/ha-berit/
[5] http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=513&letter=P&search=Presbyter#ixzz0wxl14Go5 , Article entitled "PRESBYTER" by: Richard Gottheil and Samuel Kraus.
[6] http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=696&letter=C&search=Hakam#ixzz0wxmjLEEv
[7] Beare, F. W. (1970), The First Epistle of Peter, 3rd Edition Revised, Oxford: Blackwell, p. 188.
[8] Elliot,
J. H. (2000), The Anchor Bible: 1 Peter, New York: Doubleday, p. 817.
[9] Jobes, K. H. (2009), Baker Exegetical Commentary On The New Testament: 1 Peter, Grand Rapids: Michigan, Baker Publishing House, pp. 300-301.
[10] Jobes, K. H. (2009), Baker Exegetical Commentary On The New Testament: 1 Peter, Grand Rapids: Michigan, Baker Publishing House, p. 306.
[11] Llewelyn, S. R. (1994), New Documents illustrating Early Christianity: A Review of the Greek Inscriptions and Papyri Published in 1982-83, North Ryde: New South Wales, Ancient History Documentary Research Centre, Macquarie University, p. 240